GROBLER V PHILLIPS AND OTHERS (CCT 243/21) [2022] ZACC 32 (20 SEPTEMBER 2022)

Ngomhla we-20 Septemba 2022, iNkundla yoMgaqo-siseko, emva kweminyaka elishumi elinesithathu yematyalana, yathatha isigqibo esichasene nomthengi weKliniki yezoMthetho yaseStellenbosch University, uMs Clara Phillips, oneminyaka engama-85, kunye nonyana wakhe onesiphazamiso sengqondo.
INkundla yagqiba ekubeni iminqweno yomhlali ongahlaliyo ngokusemthethweni yokuhlala endaweni ahlala kuyo iminyaka engama-74 ayibalulekanga, kuba umhlali ongahlaliyo ngokusemthethweni akanalo ilungelo lokwala ukugxothwa esekelwe kwinto yokuba uthanda okanye unqwenela ukuhlala kwindawo leyo.
Xa inika umyalelo wokugxothwa, iNkundla yathi esi sigqibo asiyi kwenza ukuba uPhillips angabi nendawo yokuhlala, kuba kuya kufuneka nje ukuba afuduke esuka kwikhaya elinye aye kwelinye elikufutshane ngaphakathi kuluntu lwaseSomerset West.
INkundla yenze lo myalelo ulandelayo:
  1. Imvume yesibheno yanikezelwa.
  2. Isibheno saphumelela.
  3. Umyalelo weNkundla ePhakamileyo yezibheno warhoxiswa, kwaza kwamiselwa lo myalelo ulandelayo endaweni yawo:
    1. UGrobler uyakunyanzeliswa ukuba athenge indawo yokuhlala enamagumbi amabini ekwimeko entle.
    2. Indawo yokuhlala kufuneka:
      1. Ibe namagumbi okulala amabini ubuncinane.
      2. Ibe neloungi, ikhitshi, kunye negumbi lokuhlambela.
      3. Ibekufuphi, kungadluli iikhilomitha ezi-5 ukusuka kwi-59 Drummer Street, Somerset West.
  4. Ibe lula ukufikelela kuyo, ingakumbi ngenxa yobudala bukaPhillips kunye nesimo sika-Adam.
  5. Xa indawo yokuhlala ibhalisiwe egameni likaGrobler, uPhillips kunye nonyana wakhe, uAdam, bayakuba nelungelo lokuhlala apho ubomi bukaPhillips bonke. UGrobler uyakunyanzeliswa ukuba abhalise eli lungelo kwitayitile yepropati.
  6. UGrobler uyakuhlawula zonke iindleko zokufuduka kukaPhillips noAdam, kuquka iindleko zokuhambisa ifenitshala nezinto zabo.
  7. UPhillips noAdam baza kuba noxanduva lokuhlawula iinkonzo zikamasipala kunye nokulungisa izinto zangaphakathi zendlu.
  8. Kufuneka bahambelane nemigaqo kamasipala kunye nemithetho ye-body corporate, ukuba iyasebenza.
  9. Ukuba uPhillips noAdam abangatshintshela kule ndawo intsha zingaphelanga iinyanga ezintandathu emva kokuba ibhalisiwe egameni likaGrobler, kufuneka baphume kwindawo abahlala kuyo e-59 Drummer Street. Ukuba abayiphumi, uSheriff weNkundla uya kuba noxanduva lokubagxotha.
  10. Akukho mntu uya kuba noxanduva lokuhlawula iindleko zomthetho zale nkqubo.